Other Events:

• FindaGrave Memorial ID: 46897066
• 1860 Census: 10 Jul 1860, Charlton, Saratoga County, New York
• Census: 16 Jun 1865, Charlton, Saratoga County, New York; 1865 New York State
• 1870 Census: 9 Jun 1870, Charlton, Saratoga County, New York
• 1880 Census: 5 Jun 1880, Cohoes, Albany County, New York

Notes:

From Findagrave:

John's residence at time of death was New York City. He died from Tuberculosis.
He had a daughter, Ethel.

Christened:
Ancestry.com. U.S., Presbyterian Church Records, 1701-1970
Name:       James Marvin Hall
Event Type:       Baptism
Baptism Date:       13 May 1853
Baptism Place:       Bergen, New Jersey, USA
Church:       First Presbyterian Church
Father:       Gilbert Hall
Mother:       Minerva Hall
____________

Name:       Jas Marvin Hall
Baptism Age:       4
Event Type:       Baptism
Birth Date:       13 May 1853
Baptism Date:       17 May 1857
Baptism Place:       Bergen, New Jersey, USA
Church:       First Presbyterian Church
Father:       Gilbert Hall

1857       Name                     Birth
May 17   Ja's Marvin Hall       May  13, 1853     Gilbert Hall.
May 17   Anna Minerva Hall    Mar. 12, 1855     Minerva M. Hall

FindaGrave Memorial ID:
https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/46897066

1860 Census:
North Galway PO, p. 96
Gilbert L Hall      40  M   Farmer   $4000  $6000  [New York]
Minerva M         38   F                                           "
Matilda P           11   F                                           "             school
Mary E               9   F                                           "                 "
James M            7   M                                           "                 "
Gilbert M            3   M                                           "
Minor Hall         48   M                  -----   $2000       "
... 3 servants

Census:
Farm
Gilbert L Hall     45  M    Head   Putnam         Md2  Md     Flown Merchant   New York City  Native  Land Owner
Julia W            35   F    Wife   Saratoga       Md1
Matilda P          16   F     Dau   New York C
Mary E             14   F     Dau         "           
James M          12   M     Son         "
Gilbert M            8   M     Son    New Jersey

1870 Census:
Charlton PO, p. 29a
Hall, Gilbert L     50  M  W   Farmer  $5,000  $25,000    New York              citizen
---, Julia W        40  F  W   Keeping House                      "
---, Matilda P      21  F  W   Teaching School                    "
---, Mary E         19  F  W                                               "         school
---, James M      17  M  W                                               "             "
---, Gilbert M      12  M  W                                               "             "
... 1 servant

1880 Census:
ED 60, p. 44
Hall, Julia     W  F   50  Widow  Wd   Housekeeper       NY  NY  NY
---, Matilda   W  F   30  Dau       S     Teacher              NY  NY  NY
---, Mary      W  F   28  Dau       S        "                      NY  NY  NY
---, James    W  M  26  Son       S      Grocery Dealer   NY  NY  NY
---, Gilbert    W  M  22  Son       S            "                   NY  NY  NY

Died:
Ancestry.com. New York, New York, Extracted Death Index, 1862-1948
Name:       James M Hall
Age:       64
Birth Year:       abt 1853
Death Date:       12 Jul 1917
Death Place:       Manhattan, New York, USA
Certificate Number:       21527